Watson And Holmes #5 Review

by @WednesdayComix on Nov 16, 2013

Can an urban re-imagining of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's character Sherlock Holmes yield a fresh take on a Victorian classic? The answer is yes.

The Good

It was Wednesday: New Comic Book Day. As I stepped through the doors of my local shop, I caught eyes with an acquaintance who was also a creator that lived in the neighborhood. Right away we exchanged smiles and greeted one another by name. Then he asked me, "Have you checked out "Watson and Holmes" yet?" There was a gleam in his eyes as he held up a copy of it. "It's an urban spin on Sherlock Holmes featuring a mostly black cast of characters." As an African-American writer and artist, it was his goal and obligation to promote not only his work and that of other writers and artists; but to call attention to good comics in general. He said that the series written by Karl Bollers and drawn by Larry Stroman reminded him of the days of emerging, indie creators and titles such as those featured at Milestone Comics back in the early 90's. I was reluctant for a moment, but I'd already intended to try something new that day. So then, "Watson and Holmes #5" was it; and it did not disappoint.

There were several things that I appreciated about this book other than the black cast. First, Bollers and Stroman dared to take a risk. Sherlock Holmes and Dr. John Watson are two of the most prominent characters in English literature, and their stories are known throughout the world. With "Sherlock" portrayed by Benedict Cumberbatch on the BBC and Robert Downey Jr. playing the detective in the Guy Ritchie movies, how does one stand out, write a strong narrative without re-hashing old stories and still honor established tropes? Bollers did so by weaving into this one-shot urban issues that has historically impacted the black community. Teen pregnancy, abortion, divorce, single-parenting and black fathers were just a few that showed up. Bollers was not preachy about it either. For example, Dr. Watson is a recent divorcee who happens to take fathering his son seriously, though that son lives with his mother. The dialogue, though stilted at times, addressed other issues naturally as Watson and Holmes raced to solve a rash of infant kidnappings in poor neighborhoods.

Secondly, Bollers demonstrated a strong sense of geography. The series is set in Harlem, New York City. He mentioned names of real streets and locations to paint the back-drop of the city. He seamlessly incorporates the infamous 221B Baker Street address into the brownstone neighborhoods of Harlem.

Thirdly, both Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson are African-American. Stroman did an effective job creating a world that was gritty, urban and diverse. The characters in the book were drawn uniquely without feeding into stereotypes about what it means to be "black." Stroman incorporated afrocentric traits from hair textures and hairstyles to nose sizes, skin tones, and facial structures. Each required a skilled eye for fashion and culture made rich across different segments of the African-American community.

The Not So Good

I believe that art should be a portal into the story. Although the art was good, it was not inviting. I had a hard time slipping into the world of "Watson and Holmes." I had to rely heavily on the writing. I also wanted more intrigue surrounding the mysterious infant kidnappings. I wanted to be more surprised by the "whodunit" than blah about how Holmes figured it out. I thought solving the crime was too pedestrian and easy for Holmes.

The Bottom Line

There is a market out there for comic books featuring stories with strong, minority characters in them as leads. It's a small market, but it's a growing one. It's mainly writers and artists of color that continue to bring attention to them. If you're curious, check out "Watson and Holmes #5."

3.0 / 5
Did you like this review?
Thanks for you vote!


Watson And Holmes #5
Released November 6, 2013
Writer Karl Bollers
Artist Larry Stroman
Cover Artist Larry Stroman

Copyright © 2010-2018 GoCollect.com & GoCollect, LLC. All Rights Reserved.

All Item images are used solely for identification purposes.
All rights to item images reserved by their respective copyright holders.

Get the most out of your chirps with these few tips:

  1. Use @username to mention a specific user.
  2. Use @GCIN (replace GCIN with the proper number) to mention an individual item.
  3. Use #subdomain to mention a specific collection. To find the subdomain of a collection, simply look up in your browser's address bar. The subdomain is the letters that follow the 'http://', but come before the '.gocollect.com'. For example, the subdomain for comics.gocollect.com would just be comics (used as #comics).
  4. Use a hashtag (#) directly in front of a word to make it a search link.

Bookmark This Page