Batgirl #27 Review

by @DocBenway on Jan 16, 2014

Bluebelle, the Gothtopia version of Batgirl, swoops in to save the innocents from poisonous confections. Why couldn’t Simone save the readership from having to buy Detective #27 to understand this story?

The Good

Barbara Gorden has a happy family life and a great side gig patrolling the gleaming streets of Gothtopia for non-existent crimes as the heroine Bluebelle. Say what? Happy family life? This is the Gordon clan. Divorce, homicidal brothers and spinal injuries via the Clown Price of Crime do not a happy family make. But that was back in the Gotham days and now we’re in… Gothtopia. Gothtopia is the shiny happy version of Gotham where everyone’s life is perfect. Think of it as a nicer version Metropolis or, sticking with Superman analogies, Bizzaro-Gotham. Gail Simone does a nice job of lending this benign landscape a Stepford Wives creepiness. Robert Gill adds extra perkiness to Barbara and manages to smooth the world-weariness from Commissioner Gorden and most of the stubble from Lieutenant Bullock. When the façade of Gothtopia begins to crack, it was almost comforting to see the rot of the true Gotham seeping through. Simone uses this juxtaposition to gently remind us just how much the city is an integral part of the Bat-family.

The Not So Good

Tie-ins don’t generally bother me. At their worst they’re just another marketing mechanism to get readers to pick up a couple of extra books. This one is a bit of tough pill to swallow because you really need to read the Gothtopia story in Detective #27 to have any clue of what’s going on. And, in case you missed it, that’s a $7.99 investment. Burying critical plot points in an oversized montage anniversary fandango just feels greedy. Focusing the above criticism to this book: Simone should have made this story stand alone. There was no reason to rely on the events that occurred in Detective to tell this portion of the story. It was also disappointing to see how quickly Batman figured out the true nature of Gothtopia while Batgirl aka Bluebelle floundered along on the mystery–solving path.

The Bottom Line

The reliance on events in other Bat titles feels like a step backward from the independence that Simone has given these characters to date. Here’s hoping she can get back to business when this Gothtopia storyline fades away.

2.5 / 5
Did you like this review?
Thanks for you vote!


Batgirl #27
Released January 15, 2014
Writer Gail Simone
Artist Fernando Pasarin
Cover Artist Alex Garner

Copyright © 2010-2018 & GoCollect, LLC. All Rights Reserved.

All Item images are used solely for identification purposes.
All rights to item images reserved by their respective copyright holders.

Get the most out of your chirps with these few tips:

  1. Use @username to mention a specific user.
  2. Use @GCIN (replace GCIN with the proper number) to mention an individual item.
  3. Use #subdomain to mention a specific collection. To find the subdomain of a collection, simply look up in your browser's address bar. The subdomain is the letters that follow the 'http://', but come before the ''. For example, the subdomain for would just be comics (used as #comics).
  4. Use a hashtag (#) directly in front of a word to make it a search link.

Bookmark This Page